THE CRITIC

Written by Patrick Marber, Anthony Quinn

Directed by Arnand Tucker

Transmission Films

In Cinemas from October 3

 

Previewed by Len Power 25 September 2024

 

Theatre and theatre critics have always had an uneasy relationship. Reviews of shows are often viewed as a necessary evil. A good review of a show can boost box office takings while a poor review may have the opposite effect. Critics have at times been so powerful, they could make or break a show with a single review.

A cruel personal review may amuse the reader but it can have a devastating effect on a performer. Ask any actor who has received one and they can quote it from memory, even if it was written years ago.

In the film, “The Critic”, a famous and feared theatre critic in 1930s London involves a vulnerable young actress in a blackmail scheme to discredit his employer, the new owner of the newspaper that he writes for. The result is devastating for all concerned.

Ian McKellen plays the critic, Jimmy Erskine. Aware of his powerful position, Erskine feels invulnerable and his behaviour and treatment of those around him is appalling. McKellen gives this character a colourful theatricality that is initially amusing but Erskine soon loses our sympathy as his evil nature comes through. It is an exceptional performance of great depth.

Ian McKellen (Jimmy Erskine)

Gemma Arteton gives a fine performance as Nina Land, the vulnerable young actress who is desperate for Erskine’s approval and there is good work from Alfred Enoch as Erskine’s live-in assistant, Tom, Lesley Manville as Nina’s mother and Mark Strong as David Brooke, Erskine’s new employer.

Ian Mckellen (Jimmy Erskine) and Gemma Arteton (Nina Land)

“The Critic” is a good film with a memorable performance of pure evil by McKellen. It will certainly appeal to those with an interest in the theatre world and, for others, it has a rattling good blackmail plot with plenty of twists and turns to keep you guessing.

 

Len Power's reviews are also broadcast on Artsound FM 92.7 in the ‘Arts Cafe’ and ‘Arts About’ programs and published in his blog 'Just Power Writing' at https://justpowerwriting.blogspot.com/.