Crims.
Written and directed by Christopher Samuel Carroll. Stage Manager Riley Winnett. Lighting Designer Disa Swifte. Set Designer. Roz Hall. The Q Theatre Queanbeyan Palarang Prforming Arts Centre. Bare Witness Theatre Company. November 19-22. Bookings 62856290
Reviewed by Peter Wilkins
Jacques Le Coq meets Bertolt Brecht in Christoper Samuel Carroll’s Crims. Set in the sleazy seedy world of Sydney’s Underworld of the 1920s Carroll’s play tells the story of the criminals who inhabited the bars, saloons, billiard halls and dark alleyways and criminal haunts of gangsters, pimps, prostitutes, politicians and bagmen, Roz Hall’s evocative setting of galvanized iron, telegraph poles and wooden boxes conjures a sense of the time reflected in the costuming and Disa Swifte’s lighting. Musicians Jesse Hill on Trumpet and Accordion, and Yile Zhang on Double Bass provide instrumental backing from the soulful era of jazz.
Carroll has taken a highly stylized approach to the story. The actors wear white makeup on their faces, highlighting the clowning and physical theatre of the show. It is agile, electric and daring, capturing the danger and violence of a time ruled by the bosses of the underword. Miriam Slater exudes the steely threat of Tilly Devine while Jack Shanahan captures the wiry cunning of the cop on the chase. Marcel Cole is a ruthless coldblooded henchman. Gabriel Sinclair is the opportunistic safecracker. Piumi Wijesundara takes on a number of roles of crim and victim as does Petronella Van Tiernan as petty crim and temptress of the night. Carroll directs with a sharp eye for the detail of gesture and movement to highlight character and action. His training at the Le Coqu school of Clowning and Mime imbues the show with atmosphere, which is well served by Cole’s Le Coq training also. Hall’s set provides the perfect backdrop for the time and there is a sense of Australia’s Soho in the back blocks of Redfern. This could be Mac The Knife’s warehouse and Carroll’s characters Brecht’s gangster’s.
The dilemma I have in reviewing Carroll’s Crims is that the dialogue was largely incomprehensible. I asked others whether they understood the actors and was met with the same response. I am willing to confess that my hearing is not as sharp as that of a younger person, but I had no trouble whatsoever understanding Cole and Shanahan and snatches of dialogue from the other actors but it was apparent that the physical demand of the show took its toll on diction and clarity and breathing. There were moments of poetic prose but by and large I was left in the dark, left only to define the narrative by the action of the characters.
![]() |
What is more puzzling is that Carroll had some very strong cast members of whom only Shanahan and Cole with their direct address style and vocal exaggeration appropriate to the style were able to successfully deliver the text throughout the play. Carroll’s play would be better served if it were presented as a silent movie with captions and voiceovers. It would suit the period and it would capture the flavour and intent of a script that too often could not be understood. The play was advertised as one hour twenty without an interval and ran for almost thirty minutes over the advertised time. Of course it was not written as a silent movie and I hope that after the opening night, Carroll and his cast will be able to give the script the importance of place that it deserves.
Crims appears to still be a work in progress and Carrol now needs to return to the text, the plot and the structure in order to make Crims the compelling work that it promises to be. Crims is a new work still in the making. The physical performances by the cast reflect remarkable local talent, some with national and international stature. If you are interested in witnessing the creation of new and innovative work at The Q then Crims is worth a visit.
Photos: Andrew Sikorski




