Sunday, September 16, 2018

BELOVED MUSE - EMILIE FLÖGE


Beloved Muse – Emilie Flöge by Penny Black.


Directed by Heidelinde Leutgoeb. Music Georg Buxhofer. Lighting Jed Buchanan. Stage management William Malam. Produced by Belvedere. Supported by the Austrian Embassy Canberra. Street Two. The Street Theatre, September 13-16. 2018


Reviewed by Peter Wilkins

Gustav Klimt and Emilie Flöge in her original strip[ed dress

 

Who amongst the art lovers of the world has not heard of Gustav Klimt, the charismatic leader of Vienna’s Secession Movement of the early twentieth Century? Who is not familiar with his iconic portrait in glittering gold of a man and woman in an intimate embrace?  Many may consider the man in the famous portrait of The Kiss to be a self portrait. But what of the model? What does the viewer know of the model and muse in the painting?
Maxi Blaha as Emilie Flöge

Enter Viennese actress, Maxi Blaha,  a vision of elegant composure, statuesque in her diaphanous dress, autocratic with her hair piled high in fashionable style, gracefully moving across the patterned carpet to sit on the low wooden bench.  Alongside her, musician Georg Buxhofer on electric bass punctuates her  solo performance with accompanying chords.

Blaha is the ideal vision of Klimt’s model, muse and intellectual partner of twenty seven years, Emilie Flöge.  And yet, how many people know of her life, as extraordinary as that of her famous artist. For a thoroughly absorbing hour, Blaha introduces us to the chapters of Flöge’s life and the enormous influence she had on Klimt’s work as well as the Viennese haute couture fashion and lifestyle.

From the outset we are introduced to a woman of strong character, an independent woman, in business with her sisters at their dress salon, Sisters Flöge on the fashionable Mariahilferstrasse. Playwright Penny Black leads us on a chronological journey through key episodes in this remarkable woman’s life. Flöge’s story commences at the time of Klimt’s death in February 1918. It is said that Klimt’s final words were “Get Emilie” or “Emilie must come” But Flöge is no lapdog to succumb to a master’s demanding call. She is a woman of independent means and independent will, a partner, who would provide dresses for Klimt’s models while he would send his clients to Flöge’s salon to buy clothes that cost the price of a small house on Lake Attersee, disbanded of corsets and inspired the fashions of Coco Chanel.
The Kiss by Gustav Klimt


Beloved Muse – Emilie Flöge reveals a feminist of strong convictions, confronting and challenging convention. Blaha presents a woman, capable of jealousy, loyal and devoted, resourceful and strongly opinionated. She criticizes Klimt’s misogynistic view of the lovers in The Kiss with the woman in a suppliant pose while the dominant male figure hovers over her. Blaha invites the audience to look beyond the image to glean a deeper meaning in a performance that is as thought provoking as it is illuminating and entertaining. 

This gentle gem of a show suffers no ostentation. Revelations of the disastrous events of the Great Depression, the Second World War and the tragic destruction of Flöge’s costumes and Klimt’s sketches in a bombed house in Vienna are told with simple sentiment, all the more dramatic for their philosophical acceptance of life’s misfortunes. Buxhofer’s musical accompaniment and Blaha’s removal of the reversible dress, made with eighteen metres of material to reveal a simple black slip reveals a woman of our time and all time, a woman, customarily depicted as a victim of the stereotype and yet, through Black’s one woman play and Blaha’s measured and intimate performance , revealed as an icon in her own right, a modern role model for all women of all time. Klimt’s muse is the muse for all society, and Maxi Blaha the perfect woman to bring Emilie Flöge to the world.

SORROWFUL SONGS - NATIONAL CAPITAL ORCHESTRA CONCERT


Musical director: Leonard Weiss
Louise Page, Soprano
Llewellyn Hall 15 September

Reviewed by Len Power




Three very different items were presented in the latest National Capital Orchestra concert and the orchestra met the individual challenges of these works very well.

The concert commenced with the well-known Vltava (‘The Moldau’), the second movement from Má vlast (My Country) by Czech composer, Bedřich Smetana.  It was played very well by the orchestra, bringing out the full colour and nationalistic emotion of this melodic and illustrative work.

Commissioned for the opening ceremony of the 2006 Commonwealth Games, Christopher Gordon’s ‘Ceremonial Games’ was given its world concert premiere by the orchestra.  The suite comprises three movements taken from the thirteen of the original event music.  ‘The Arrival’ is suitably grand and exciting and has a very interesting jazz-like section towards the end.  ‘Raising the Flag’ with its appealing and unexpected percussion was especially well-played by the orchestra.  ‘The Celebration’ was a dramatic and vibrant finale for the suite.  The composer was in the audience and gave conductor, Leonard Weiss, the thumbs-up at the end.  He had every reason to be pleased as the orchestra played it very well.

Louise Page, Leonard Weiss and Christopher Gordon

After interval, Canberra soprano, Louise Page, joined the orchestra for Symphony No. 3, Op. 36, “Symphony of Sorrowful Songs” by Henryk Górecki.  This powerful minimalist work, written in 1976, is in three movements.  The first, based around a text taken from a 15th century Polish monastic lament, was sung with great precision and quiet emotion by Louise Page.

Louise Page and Leonard Weiss

The second movement, taken from a few lines written on a prison wall from World War 2, was sung with heart-breaking simplicity, making it a very moving experience for the audience.  The orchestra’s playing of the final passages of this movement was exceptional.  The folk song in the final movement is a song of grief by a mother who has lost her son.  Louise Page sang it with a warmth and tenderness that was deeply affecting.

This was a fine concert with good choices of works played very well by the orchestra with another memorable vocal performance by Louise Page.

Photos by Peter Hislop

Len Power’s reviews are also broadcast in his ‘On Stage’ performing arts radio program on Mondays and Wednesdays from 3.30pm on Artsound FM 92.7.

Saturday, September 15, 2018

THE SEASON




 
 
Written by Nathan Maynard – Produced by Tasmania Performs
Directed by Isaac Drandic – Designed by Richard Roberts

Lighting designed by Rachel Burke – Sound composed and designed by Ben Grant

The Playhouse, Canberra Theatre Centre – 13 – 15 September 2018

Performance on 13th September reviewed by Bill Stephens

Nathan Maynard’s elegiac, slice-of-life love letter to his family shines a spotlight on an aboriginal community which for generations has eked out a living harvesting baby mutton birds during the annual mutton birding season on Tasmania’s remote Big Dog Island.   The journey to the mutton bird rookeries is a tradition Tasmanian aborigines have undertaken for hundreds of years. Maynard’s play focusses on the Duncan family, led by patriarch Ben (Maitland Schnaars) and his wife, Stella (Della Rae Morrison), who are hosting a reunion for the birding season.

The Duncan Family 
Della Rae Morrison (Stella) - Maitland Schnaars (Ben) - James Slee (front-Clay)
Mathew Cooper (Ritchie) - Lisa Mazza (Marlene) - Nazaree Dickerson (Lou)
 
Helping out are their cocky son Ritchie (Mathew Cooper), their daughter Lou (Nazaree Dickerson) and her teenage son, Clay (James Slee) who lives in Melbourne and is having his first experience harvesting mutton birds. Clay is keen to succeed at mutton birding but is distracted by the fact that his no-good white father has not turned up as promised.

Not a lot happens on Big Dog Island, and so the Duncans spend their time bickering over early morning breakfasts, and sharing secrets during late night parties on the beach or during sweaty days in the plucking sheds. There is little drama in their interaction, not the least because of the scatter-gun delivery of some of the cast, which made it difficult to catch many of the lines.

Trevor Jamieson (Neil) - Lisa Mazza (Marlene) 
 
 
The  funniest and most compelling moments are generated by the exuberant performances of Lisa Mazza as Stella’s potty-mouthed sister Marlene, and Trevor Jamieson as her impish, randy no-hoper boyfriend, Neil, and the repercussions of Marlene's decision, after some comical canoodling on the beach, to end her long-term affair with Neil, which leads to the revelation from Lou, that she’s lesbian.
Charismatic Jamieson also doubles as the ranger, but his magnificent white beard is so distinctive that it’s impossible to accept that the ranger is not Neil in his day job.

Apart from its depiction of family dynamics, the main interest is the play is enactment of the rituals associated with mutton birding. Much of the dialogue takes place as the young birds, represented by white rags, are dragged from their nests, their necks broken, and then strung on long sticks and carried off to the plucking sheds.

There are poetic moments in the references to the mutton birds which migrate thousands of kilometres each year, only to return to the same burrows to breed, and in the scene in which young Clay summons up the courage to plunge his arm into a mutton bird burrow, and then deciding to release the precious white mutton bird leader he discovers.

Richard Robert’s spare panoramic setting effectively conjures up the remoteness of the island beaches, and the plucking sheds, but it’s a pity that a better solution could not have been found for the all-important kitchen scenes, which are cramped to one side of the stage.

With “The Season” Maynard has written a shrewd, charming play  memorable for the uniqueness of its setting, its colourful characters who like the mutton birds return each year to their special island, and for the insights it offers into little-known activity of mutton-birding.

                                                         Photos by James Henry
 
        This review also appears in Australian Arts Review. www.artsreview.com.au

 

FADING

Fading by  Laura Lethlean.

Directed by Katie Cawthorne. Assistant director Stefanie Lekkas. Lighting Ethan Hamill. Additional sound. Kimmo Vennonen. Piano recording Elektra Spencer. Canberra Youth Theatre. Courtyard Studio. Canberra Theatre Centre. September 12 – 15 2018.

Reviewed by Peter Wilkins

 


A solitary swing is the only item of set upon the stage at the Courtyard Studio where Canberra Youth Theatre is staging Laura Lethlean’s play Fading. Tim Minchin recently remarked that he defies anyone to pass by a swing and not be lured back in time to the joyful experience of floating through the air, carefree and swathed in the wonderment of childhood. Lethlean takes us back to the wistful, happy era of curious excitement, enveloping us in nostalgia and the memory of playfulness, fantasy and wide-eyed optimism. The ensemble enter, fresh faced and eager in their anticipation of a promising future, guided by an authority figure with the responsibility of teaching the child the expanding avenues of their universe. It is the time of innocence, soon to be invaded by the advancing perils of the river of adolescence and the torrential tides of adulthood. The trickling water of childhood, tingling the toes to delighted giggles rises with alarming alacrity, dragging the youth beneath the surface as the playful games turn into an ominous recollection of the childhood story, We’re Going on a Bear Hunt and the playful chant turns to a daunting challenge of equally fearful choices that ultimately can only be faced by  embracing the secure support of community.

Canberra Youth Theatre’s talented ensemble, under the imaginative and energetic direction of Katie Cawthorne, once again have created a work that epitomizes with integrity and skill the role of youth theatre in reflecting through the theatre arts the aspirations, dreams, hopes and fears of young people. The outstanding ensemble of players in Fading stand  at the cusp of adulthood, having passed through the imaginative playfulness of childhood, the angst and confusion of adolescence to reach the trepidation of adulthood.   Through a series of effectively staged vignettes, the cast play out the shifting emotions and desires. Lethlean’s pithy and direct dialogue of one liners, supported by the committed input by the young actors is dreamlike during childhood, urgent during adolescence and hopefully  resolved on the precipice of adulthood. Individuality still survives amidst the pressures to conform, but we are left with a feeling of loss and fading dreams.

Fading is the unabashed voice of the tribe. It will resonate with the force of recollection, at times nostalgic, at times fearful, at times courageous and independent. Those of the tribe in the audience will identify. Those who have passed through and survived will empathise and all will reflect on the fading of the times and the experience. For the cast, there is catharsis and the search for identity. Cawthorne creates a theatre of physical impulse setting up  a chain reaction as the cast traverse the stage, gather in tight groups, and echo repetitive calls of the group.  The staging is dynamic in its propulsion, offering strength in unity and assertive commitment to Lethlean’s text and Cawthorne’s direction.

Fading is not the stereotypical well-made play. Its structure is purposefully reflective, though not didactic and it exudes honesty and commitment. As such, it demands earnest attention from the audience who are not required to follow a plot or immerse themselves in the story of a particular character. They are invited, in Brechtian terms, to listen, watch, hear and consider. This requires excellent vocal and physical technique and although the physical work in this show is outstanding, and the commitment to the work highly commendable, vocal work tends to be uneven, except in the case of certain members of the ensemble. With a work so episodic and fast paced, it is imperative that it communicates effectively through body, thought and voice.

Notwithstanding this, Canberra Youth Theatre’s production of Fading is another fine example of the excellent work created by the young people and their tutors at CYT. It is relevant, insightful and  a theatrically dynamic and entertaining example of its genre.


   

What Matters? Talking Value in Australian Culture






What Matters? Talking Value in Australian Culture by Julian Meyrick, Robert Phiddian and Tully Barnett.  Monash University Publishing, Melbourne 2018.

Reviewed by Frank McKone


What Matters?, a product of Laboratory Adelaide in an ARC-funded Linkage project based at Flinders University,  is an academic work of inestimable value to critics in the arts.  To explain why requires me, to be consistent with the book’s approach, to provide you with an anecdote, titled

The Parable of Being Fair to My Lady

In 1956, a teenager named Frank, already enamoured of the work of George Bernard Shaw, heard Julie Andrews singing Eliza Doolittle on his newly acquired original Broadway cast LP and fell in love again – with both the performer and the character.  He even learned to play all the tunes on his Hohner chromatic harmonica in the manner of Larry Adler.

Though My Fair Lady was a commercial success and has continued to be so to this very day, Frank had a niggling feeling through all those years.  Did Julie Andrews, he worried, feel satisfied with Eliza Doolittle’s ending?  He knew, of course, that Bernard Shaw sent Eliza off at the end of Pygmalion to run her own life in her own way regardless of Henry Higgins’ self-centred feelings – in fact, maybe because of them.  But in My Fair Lady, Eliza returns to her ‘creator’ as if at least to say sorry, or even to live with him.  Maybe she might do no more than manage his affairs and put his slippers out for him.  But surely Shaw’s point in using the ancient tale of Pygmalion was to expose male chauvinism and emphasise women’s independence and human rights.

Some 50 years later, young Frank finally got see Sydney Theatre Company’s Pygmalion on stage (reviewed here February 4, 2012) and was pleased to see that Peter Evans understood Shaw’s intentions, using clever video at the end.  But Julie Andrews still niggled – until just last year when I had the chance to review Julie Andrews’ directing of My Fair Lady “adapted from George Bernard Shaw’s play and Gabriel Pascal’s motion picture Pygmalion”.  What would this mean?

Reviewing on August 30, 2017, I was fairly sure Julie Andrews had been niggled too, because she found a way of satisfying commercial sentimentality by having Eliza re-appear, but with a nodding recognition in Shaw’s direction.  I wrote:

Just before the lights dimmed on that final image, Charles Edwards turned his face away, towards the audience, and put his head down – to do what?  Hide Higgins’ embarrassment, when he had never been embarrassed before?  Hide his tears, as he realised he has lost her forever?  As a kind of joke, pretending to be a little boy?
I followed this observation with considerable discussion, rather in the manner of Shaw in his prologues.
_____________________________________________________________________________
And the point of the parable?

To quote Meyrick et al: “For now, what matters is that the ambition to turn all that we do and have into ‘an asset’ of one kind or another is extremely contentious.…it places all phenomena on a plane of theoretical equivalence.  A native forest could be valued ‘the same as’ a local golf course, or a family friend ‘the same as’ a family home…Actuaries and insurance brokers regularly put a price on objects, persons and relations we would regard as irreplaceable but which are treated as things that can be weighed and measured in standardised units, and thus compared.”

Since My Fair Lady has surely made far more money than Pygmalion, and is therefore a much greater ‘asset’, should I – as a critic – treat them as ‘equal’, or one as better than the other artistically?  Is it fair of me to say that Julie Andrews seems to know what Shaw meant, but sold him out just a bit to keep the show popular?

This is the sort of question What Matters? raises, about my role as a critic through to the role of politicians as funders of the arts. 

Let’s take the use of numbers to decide on funding:

“Used where context is understood, and subject to robust interrogation, numbers can be worth the trouble.  However they can also be a distraction from more important but less measurable purposes, and:
1. They provide little security from external blows, because funding decisions are always political and not really based on the sorts of evidence they claim to want.
2. They quickly generate internal targets that work to the metrics and not to reality, so they distort internal practice.
3. If they escape into the public realm, they become targets and rankings in next to no time.
4. And the targets have to be exceeded every year because growth is the constant expectation.”

And let’s consider the effects of ‘digital disruption’, where technology is applied to these numbers:

“Open access may make the inequalities in society we have not yet resolved more extreme.  There’s no app for that.  The age of FAANG brings with it challenges that evaluation strategies must learn to deal with.  As Julianne Schultz points out:
   
    “we are seeing a massive redistribution of wealth from the cultural sector, where meaning is created, to the technology sector, which has figured out how to market, distribute, reach and make money out of it in ways the cultural industries never imagined possible.”

Reminds me of the good old days when there was no budget for Drama, but the Principal insisted the Drama teacher put on a musical each year because it made the school look good.

You may have noticed in these couple of quotes that What Matters? reads differently from what you may expect of an academic publication.  This is where parables come in.  Instead of standard academic format and style, the authors interpolate short stories between sections of factual statement and argument.  They even justify this approach by pointing out how successful Jesus of Nazareth has been, for some 2000 years, by telling creative stories which demonstrate his rational argument.

“There is considerable overlap between academic researchers’ use of case studies and our conception of parables of value. Any competent case study will have a parabolic dimension to it, as it must tell a story exemplifying a wider set of relations or conditions.  Such an approach is not an exercise in make-believe, but a discipline of framing evidence meaningfully and holistically so readers get a sense of what is at stake in human terms without being in a particular situation themselves…. Jesus set an impressive standard in the Gospels that few organisations today can equal. Parables should draw their meaning from the context around them, and not spend much time in scene-setting. They need to be graspable in a couple of minutes, and might reasonably be given strict word limits in official assessment.”

For example, “David Marr tells the story of White and the critic Geoffrey Dutton meeting in Sydney on 24 August 1960” in which we learn how to interpret the numbers, such as audience subscription bookings and single ticket bookings, and the reception of Patrick White as a playwright (and even his decisions about whether to write plays or not) over the decades after 1960.  “The reception of White’s plays in the 1960s was not ‘wrong’. Perhaps the high position we now give them will be seen as ‘wrong’ in 50 years’ time.”

This is quite a lengthy instructive parable, but a fascinating reflection on a creative writer’s career, showing how fine detailed interpretation of numbers recorded by box offices make a nonsense of politically puerile use of simple numbers, like attendances, to inform funding decisions by government on a nation-wide basis.

I’ll leave you to read the parable of the Farnarkulator, so named, of course, in memory of the comic genius, John Clarke.

So, if numbers are problematical, where do we go instead – or at least, as well, since numbers carefully and fully understood can sometimes be useful?  Here is where we critics come in:

“The aim here, it is important to remember, is not to agree about culture, but to get better at disagreeing about it. All participants, professionals and ‘mere’ citizens must learn to talk better as enthusiastic and well-informed amateurs: as non-experts. To bridge the personal and the political, culture talk needs a robust pluralism of positions and tones.  This requires language skills as arduously acquired and profound as any expert talk.”

So now words become What Matters – like ‘excellence’ (ref George Brandis) and its replacement ‘innovation and participation’ (ref his replacement Mitch Fifield).  In the parable Buzzword Bingo, about bureaucratic language, Don Watson’s book Death Sentence is quoted:

“No doubt in the place from which these words came they
were judged competent. But they are not competent in the
world at large. They are not competent as language. They
represent an example of what Orwell calls anaesthetic
writing. You cannot read it without losing some level of
consciousness. You come to, and read it again, and still your
brain will not reveal the meaning – will not even try. You
are getting sleepy again."

“Watson points out the problem, and we all laugh. But the objects of ridicule refuse to melt away.”

Thus we reach textbox 7: A Guide to Writing about Value to be used when presenting your case for funding, when words is all you have, because (ref Beatles) words, like love, is all you need.

1. Good writing skills are not peripheral to the provision of evidence: they are the key to it.
2. Because writing is part of making a case, it should not be entirely outsourced.
3. Write to communicate not to obfuscate.
4. Be specific.
5. Carefully attend to the story you are telling.
6. Keep bullshit to a minimum.
7. Be truthful.
8. Be credible.
9. Read as carefully as you write.

“This list sounds like no more than useful health advice (eat well, exercise regularly, get plenty of sleep). Yet in Laboratory Adelaide’s view, communicating well about the value of culture is overwhelmingly a matter of clarity and honesty.”

And so we come to Narratives of Value; Reporting of Value including the Charter of Cultural Reporting: Six Principles of Meaningful Communication; and Conclusion.

“Over the four years of Laboratory Adelaide’s life we have followed debates about value wherever these have led us. We have talked to artists, academics, economists, CEOs, consultants, statisticians and artists again. Our conclusion is that government policy has reached a strange moment when quantitative measures have achieved dominant power over the least quantifiable area of human endeavour – culture.”

The Conclusion is made up of four Thoughts, with accompanying textboxes and parables – the story of Laboratory Adelaide’s life.  For me, as a critic, What Matters? Talking Value in Australian Culture places what I write in context in a much more down-to-earth way than any of my previous studies of the nature and purpose of criticism.  Maybe I’m the only one who needs it, but I recommend What Matters? to any practitioner in the arts, remembering that ““The aim here, it is important to remember, is not to agree about culture, but to get better at disagreeing about it.”



The Three of Us